Learn Liberty

on-demand-banner

Is Katniss a Modern-Day Spartacus?

Literature and legend often reflect their culture. Some themes, like that of rulers imposing coercive power, or of individuals rising up against tyrants, are as relevant today as they were in antiquity. Suzanne Collins drew on Greek mythology’s story of the Minotaur and on the legend of Spartacus in ancient Rome as she created the Hunger Games series. Her hero, like the heroes in these stories, does not seek her own power or profit but is standing up against a violent and tyrannical government. “People everywhere yearn for the freedom to pursue their own goals and dreams,” says Prof. Amy Sturgis. Even though the themes are ancient, stories like the Hunger Games resonate with readers because the anxieties and fears they portray are real and relevant. “These stories aren’t just entertainment,” Sturgis says. “They are reflections of who and what we are.” Do the themes in these stories resonate with you? Why?

http://classics.mit.edu/Plutarch/theseus.html [webpage]: John Dryden translates Plutarch’s ancient story of the Greek hero Theseus


http://www.livius.org/so-st/spartacus/spartacus.html [webpage]: Jona Lendering tells the tale of Spartacus the Roman gladiator turned revolutionary


http://www.slj.com/2010/08/authors-illustrators/the-last-battle-with-mockingjay-on-its-way-suzanne-collins-weighs-in-on-katniss-and-the-capitol/ [article]: Rick Margolis sits down with Suzanne Collins to talk about Mockingjay, Philosophy, the world of Panem, and the overall meaning of The Hunger Games


http://www.fee.org/the_freeman/detail/our-cages-and-labyrinths#axzz2lJaypHXm [article]: Jeffrey Tucker explores the many themes and ideas in The Hunger Games and other pop culture and how these themes can reflect a change in thought


http://www.cato-unbound.org/issues/july-2012/liberty-commerce-literature [articles]: A series of essays on liberty in literature


http://www.slj.com/2008/09/authors-illustrators/a-killer-story-an-interview-with-suzanne-collins-author-of-the-hunger-games/#_ [article]: Rick Margolis sits down with Suzanne Collins to talk about her motivations in writing The Hunger Games


http://eldritchhobbit.livejournal.com/tag/ya%20dystopias%20list [resource]: A list of Young Adult dystopias and secondary sources compiled by Prof. Amy Sturgis


https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/8046680-the-girl-who-was-on-fire [resource]: The Girl Who Was on Fire: Your Favorite Authors on Suzanne Collins’ Hunger Games Trilogy


https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10776887-the-hunger-games-and-philosophy [resource]: The Hunger Games and Philosophy: A Critique of Pure Treason


https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13555385-the-panem-companion [resource]: The Panem Companion


Is Katniss a Modern-Day Spartacus?
In one version of an Ancient Greek myth, the kingdom of Crete defeats Athens in war and then demands regular sacrifices to remind the conquered people of Crete’s power. Athenian boys and girls are taken as tributes, and then locked inside a vast labyrinth where they are pursued and devoured by a monstrous Minotaur. These terrible killings continue until one day a hero stands up in Athens, a young man named Theseus, who volunteers to take the place of one of the doomed boys.
Sound familiar? That’s because Suzanne Collins, the author of the popular Hunger Games books, consciously drew from legends of antiquity in writing her series. Young Theseus did prove himself a hero: With the help of the King's daughter, he finds his way through the labyrinth and slays the Minotaur.  He ends the cycle of oppression so no more tributes have to die.
In ancient Rome we find another story that may sound familiar to Hunger Games fans. Spartacus, a gladiator, is forced to fight fellow slaves to the death in an arena, a spectacle to entertain the political elite and pacify the masses.  But Spartacus refuses to be used for these gruesome games. He leads his fellow slaves in a rebellion against the Roman Empire in the first century BCE, his name becoming a rallying cry for freedom.
Katniss Everdeen, the heroine of the Hunger Games trilogy, inherits the mantle of both Theseus and Spartacus. She’s part freedom fighter, part political revolutionary, and part reluctant hero by necessity. While her world is updated to speak to our modern anxieties—her government employs sophisticated technology to spy on its citizens and even attack them; propaganda is fused with reality television—ultimately the story has so much power for us because it taps into a struggle thousands of years old.
As a professor of intellectual history who specializes in the dystopian tradition, I think it’s important to consider why these narratives resonate so well with us. The tales of Theseus, Spartacus, and Katniss are all iterations of the same story, of rulers imposing coercive power, and of individuals rising up against them. These heroes don't wish to set themselves up as new tyrants. They seek only the opportunity to determine their own lives and let others do the same. Similar heroes are found in many of the greatest stories of history, recounted in our films, our novels, our music. They stir our hearts because the struggle between  liberty and power remains a very real part of our world. People everywhere yearn for the freedom to pursue their own goals and dreams. These stories aren't just entertainment. They are reflections of who and what we are.

Right-click the link below and select "Save Link" or "Save Target."


Download MP3

17 Comments

  1. Matt Wavle

    I think it’s a telling parallel, between the State of that day and the State of the Hunger Games era.  So little has changed, other than the technology used.
    – The best way to win is to take the Spartacus path, to refuse to participate.

  2. Matt Wavle

    Amy Sturgis makes a great point. The struggle between freedom and tyranny is real.  Stories like this reflect our own hopes and dreams, and because of that, they are more powerful than most mindless entertainment.

  3. Greg Gauthier

    Theseus and the Minotaur just made me realize something: Ancients needed a historical reason for everything they did. So, often they just made up histories, to give themselves reasons. The Minotaur is an allegory explaining why the greeks no longer engaged in human sacrifice. Very much similar to the story of Abraham being stayed from sacrificing his son Isaac. 

  4. Andrei-Claudiu Roibu

    What are heroes? Only the ones that have the courage to remind us who and what we are, and what we are capable of as people, even if this costs them their lives. Despite the characters mentioned in the videos below, I would just like to remember a few Romanian heroes: Mihai Viteazul, Carol I, Ecaterina Teodoroiu, Nicolae Balcescu, Avram Iancu, the motii who arrived at the Apuseni Mountains plane crash, ant many many others. 

  5. Farid Faisal Bestari

    are the similarities between those stories an example of Joseph Campbell a hero in a thousand faces monomyth theory?  

  6. Ryan Boyd

    Freedom and liberty are common themes, and the Hunger Games trilogy is a great addition to the literature already on this topic.

  7. gab912

    yes! Because of these articles here, I’m actually thinking of transitioning to the English department in my high school…

  8. Damian Gunjak

    I ve actually listened and watched to the books and film and i have to say that while its geared towards a young adult  the bookseries certainly paints a dark picture of a totalitarian america. 

  9. kelsapellet

    It’s great when traditional stories can help us draw connections to civil discourse going on in today’s society through film adaptions. Some people don’t realize it until something like the Hunger Games makes them aware that it’s going on.

Add Comment Register



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

    LearnLiberty_Banner (1)